1. The Puzzle
The computation
yields some combination . Students are usually told to trust that this vector:
- has length = area of the parallelogram of ,
- is perpendicular to both,
- obeys the right-hand rule.
We want a reason, not brute-force verification.
2. Duality Recap
Theorem 2.1 – Dual vector
Every linear transformation is described by a matrix; tipping it on its side gives a vector with
is the dual vector of .
Plan: define a specific linear map from and ; show its dual vector is (a) what the computation gives and (b) what the geometry describes. Same dual vector ⇒ computation and geometry agree.
3. A Natural Guess and the Key Function
2D analogy
In 2D, — an ordinary determinant, an ordinary number (signed area).
A tempting 3D analogue (not the cross product)
= signed volume of the parallelepiped spanned by three vectors (sign by right-hand rule). This takes three vectors to a number — not the cross product, but close.
Definition 3.1 – The function
Make the first vector variable, keep fixed:
Geometrically: the signed volume of the parallelepiped spanned by , , .
Lemma 3.2 – is linear
(Follows from properties of the determinant — linear in each column.) Therefore has a dual vector :
4. Finding Computationally
Left side: .
Right side, expanded down the first column:
Matching coefficients:
This is exactly what you get by plugging into the first column — those symbols just flag “read these coefficients as coordinates of a vector.”
The notational trick is answering: which vector makes equal that determinant for every ?
5. Finding Geometrically
Ask the same question geometrically: which satisfies
Volume = base × height
- Base = area of the parallelogram spanned by .
- Height = component of perpendicular to that parallelogram.
So acts by: project onto the line perpendicular to and , then multiply by the parallelogram’s area.
Dot-product reading
That is precisely the dot product of with a vector that is
- perpendicular to and ,
- with length = area of their parallelogram,
- pointing in the direction that makes the signs match the right-hand rule.
6. Conclusion
| Approach | Dual vector of |
|---|---|
| Computational | The determinant trick |
| Geometric | Perpendicular to , length = parallelogram area, right-hand-rule direction |
Both are the dual vector of the same linear map ⇒ they are the same vector. That’s the fundamental reason the computation and the geometry of the cross product coincide.
Useful corollary – scalar triple product
Worked example. , , so . For : = base area × height ✓.
⚠️ Pitfall: Only the component of perpendicular to the - plane affects the volume — sliding parallel to the base doesn’t change it.
Exercises: Show is linear using determinant properties, and verify for , , (lesson page).